Australasian Science: Australia's authority on science since 1938

The Facts About Surrogacy

By Michael Cook

The dismal death of Brooke Verity illustrates the need for longitudinal studies of the long-term outcomes of surrogacy.

Whether you are pro-this or anti-that, a passionate believer in human dignity or an ultra-rational utilitarian, your bioethics always has to begin with the facts. While knowledge of consequences is only part of ethical decision-making, it is an essential part.

Surrogacy is one issue in which the public gets only a very partial vision of the consequences. Normally the media focuses on the joy of the commissioning parents, while the surrogate mother remains anonymous and her story untold. But her life after surrogacy is part of the consequences as well.

Nowhere was this more marked than in India, where some clinics had dormitories for surrogate mothers in varying stages of pregnancy. The clinics assured Western journalists that they were happy and detached. And since there was an almost impenetrable language barrier between the journalists and the women, it was practically impossible to check these bland reassurances. Now India has closed the door to international surrogacy, so the stories have ceased.

But around the world surrogacy is increasing, not decreasing, as older women and gay couples try to have children. Because it is legal in the United States, many parents are drawn there. However, the recent death of a surrogate mother in the state of Kentucky unveiled hazards that exist even in the world’s richest nation.

For a brief moment in 2002, 23-year-old Brooke Verity was probably the world’s most famous surrogate mother. She had just given birth to quadruplets for a gay couple.

The four children, who now live in California, turn 15 in July. But Brooke won’t be celebrating with them. She died suddenly in November of chronic drug abuse at the ripe old age of 37. It is a sad story and it helps to explain why Harvard women prefer careers in investment banking to careers in surrogacy.

When Brooke was 4, her parents divorced. After a year with her mother, she moved in with her father. She became pregnant at 17, had a son, married the father, had twins, and then divorced.

A couple of years later her hairdresser, Thomas Dysarz, and his partner, Michael Meehan, asked her if she would be interested in becoming a surrogate mother. She signed a contract to bear a child for each of them. She surrendered her parental rights as the biological mother and agreed to foetal reduction, if necessary. All she received in return was a tummy tuck.

After IVF with Meehan’s sperm, Brooke became pregnant with five babies. She and Meehan agreed to “reduce”, or abort, one of them. Dysarz disagreed but only four babies were born, prematurely, on 26 July 2002. And from there Brooke’s life started to go downhill.

She suffered from post-natal depression. Perhaps the men did, too. Dysarz broke up with Meehan, alleging abuse. Dysarz was denied visitation rights and Meehan was awarded custody of the quadruplets. To escape Dysarz, Meehan moved back to California.

As for the children’s mother, she just wanted to be “Aunt Brooke” to them and felt miserable that she had been shut out of their lives. She began keeping a diary for them in which the opening paragraph was: “I love you all. I’ll never regret what I did. Every single day, I’ll think about you.”

Brooke had another surrogate child for Dysarz afterwards. Then he became ill and moved interstate, abandoning the child. She was awarded full custody. In 2007 she married Scott Cochran, a maths teacher at a community college, who spent brief spells in jail for sexual misdemeanours in 2014 and 2016. Unsurprisingly, their marriage was strained and Brooke was still grieving over the quadruplets. Perhaps this explains why the mother of eight became another victim of America’s opioid epidemic.

Even after her death, the dominos are still falling. Dysarz and Cochran are locked in a custody battle over the son Brooke bore for him.

These are the kind of dismal consequences that are seldom reported in the media. Even more disturbing, they are seldom studied by academics. How many women suffer like Brooke Verity after surrogacy? It is easy to say that she was an exceptional case, but the truth is that we don’t know. How about some serious longitudinal studies of the lives of surrogate mothers?

Michael Cook is editor of BioEdge, an online bioethics newsletter.